The association for the people and businesses of Sheffield's digital industries.

Sponsor spotlight: Anthology North

Finding the right people can make or break an ambitious business. But for early-stage technology companies, where specialist skills are often in short supply and every appointment carries significant weight, getting recruitment right can be particularly challenging. It’s an area where Sam Clayton, Founder and CEO of Anthology North, believes he can make a real difference. 

Having recently joined Sheffield Digital as an Associate Sponsor, Sam is keen to bring his specialist executive search expertise closer to home, supporting Sheffield’s growing digital and technology community and helping businesses navigate some of their most important recruitment decisions.

We caught up with Sam to find out more about Anthology North, his approach to executive search and why he’s keen to contribute to the local ecosystem.

Bringing specialist tech recruitment expertise to Sheffield

Sam established Anthology Global in 2019, drawing on more than 14 years’ experience recruiting for early-stage technology start-ups and scale-ups.

Initially, much of his work focused on emerging areas of technology, science and engineering, particularly climate and environmental innovation, alongside agricultural and food innovation. However, the recruitment challenges he encountered – finding people with highly specialised skills and helping ambitious businesses build the right teams – were transferable across the wider technology sector.

Despite living just outside Sheffield, Sam’s work had largely taken him to clients elsewhere in the UK and internationally, including established technology hubs such as Cambridge, Oxford and London.

That began to change earlier this year, when he started looking more closely at the activity happening on his doorstep.

“I had this penny-drop moment of thinking, hang on, there’s so much emerging tech happening in the local area as well. I’d never really done any recruitment in Sheffield, but the more I looked beneath the surface, the more I realised there’s loads here.”

Anthology North is the result: a dedicated focus on building relationships with businesses across Sheffield and the wider North.

While it began as an offshoot of Anthology Global, Sam hopes that, over time, Anthology North will become the main focus of the business.

Sam established Anthology Global in 2019, drawing on more than 14 years’ experience recruiting for early-stage technology start-ups and scale-ups.

A different approach to executive search

Sam is keen to distinguish Anthology North from the perception some businesses have of traditional recruitment agencies.

Rather than approaching companies with a sales pitch, he wants to build relationships, understand the challenges they’re facing and offer useful advice, whether or not that leads to a recruitment assignment.

When it comes to the search itself, his approach is thorough and bespoke.

“I see our search process as our product. A lot of people say that, in recruitment, candidates are your product, but I don’t really agree with that because candidates are people. I think our product is our search methodology.”

For every assignment, Anthology North aims to cover the entire market relevant to the role, rather than relying solely on an existing network or database of candidates. That can mean looking nationally or internationally to find the right person.

Sam keeps the number of assignments he takes on relatively low, usually working on one or two searches at a time. This allows him to invest several weeks in understanding the brief and identifying the strongest possible candidates.

And the process begins, according to Sam, well before the search itself. He believes businesses need to understand what they’re really looking for, starting with their own values, working culture and ambitions, before defining the technical requirements of a role.

“Everything about what you’re looking for should work backwards from your actual business goal,” he says. “What are you trying to accomplish?”

Sam also encourages founders to be honest about the realities of working in their business, including the less comfortable aspects of their own working styles.

Values, he argues, are often treated as a marketing exercise, with businesses presenting an idealised version of themselves. In reality, understanding what a company is genuinely like – including its quirks and challenges – is essential to finding someone who will thrive there. He explains,

“None of us are perfect. We’ve all got our own idiosyncrasies. There are probably things about you that are amazing and make you really easy to work with, but there are probably traits that can be a bit difficult to work with at times. What are those? What’s somebody else going to have to be able to deal with?”

Start-ups in particular can be tempted to sell the dream without explaining the challenges that come with joining an early-stage business.

Sam believes the best recruitment outcomes stem from being upfront about both.

“Yes, sell the dream, but sell it honestly as well.”

Understanding the recruitment challenges facing tech businesses

Through his work with start-ups and growing technology companies, Sam has seen some recurring recruitment challenges.

One of the most significant is the pressure associated with making those first few hires. For a founder who has built a business around their own specialist expertise, bringing in someone with a completely different skill set can feel like a considerable leap of faith.

He also regularly encounters the assumption that Sheffield doesn’t have the talent pool to support highly specialised technology businesses. It’s a view he doesn’t entirely agree with.

“Recruiting for an exceptionally niche role is difficult wherever you are in the world. The challenge,” Sam suggests, “is knowing where to look and how to communicate the opportunity effectively.”

And he believes Sheffield has plenty to offer prospective recruits from elsewhere.

He points to the growing number of examples of people choosing to relocate to the city, attracted by its emerging technology scene, its collaborative business community and its proximity to the outdoors. For businesses looking to attract specialist talent from further afield, being able to tell that wider Sheffield story is increasingly important.

Another common challenge is identifying the right first commercial hire.

Sam says that, in his experience, when a technology founder approaches him about making their first appointment, it’s often a commercial lead they’re looking for. The founder may have the technical expertise to develop an innovative product but needs someone who can take it to market and build a customer base.

Founders sometimes want an experienced commercial director who can set strategy and lead a growing team, while also being prepared to undertake the hands-on work of generating leads, making cold calls and securing those first customers.

Sam points out that those are very different demands, and finding someone who can genuinely fulfil both isn’t always realistic.

Part of his role is therefore to help founders challenge their assumptions, refine their requirements and understand what they actually need at that stage of their business.

It’s an approach that also applies to more established organisations. Even within a large company, individual teams have their own cultures, dynamics and requirements, all of which need to be considered when making an appointment.

Making recruitment decisions with confidence

So when should a business consider bringing in specialist executive search support rather than managing recruitment itself?

Based on his experience, Sam identifies three particularly relevant scenarios:

The first is when a business needs to recruit for a role that’s going to be genuinely difficult to fill, perhaps because the skills required are exceptionally niche or the talent pool is spread internationally.

The second is when a business needs confidence that it has considered the entire available market and identified the strongest possible candidate. This can be particularly important where recruitment decisions need to be evidenced to investors or other stakeholders. Anthology North provides clients with a transparent account of the search, including the market covered, the candidates approached and the reasons behind their decisions, bringing that information together in a final report.

The third is when a business wants to reduce the risks associated with making an important appointment.

However, Sam is also realistic about when external support isn’t necessary. If a business can attract good candidates through its own networks or a straightforward job advert, he would encourage it to explore those options first.

There is also the question of time. Businesses sometimes underestimate how much internal resource a recruitment process can consume, particularly when they don’t have the experience or capacity to manage it effectively.

Outsourcing the process can free founders and senior teams to concentrate on running and growing the business.

Supporting Sheffield’s technology community

Sam’s growing involvement in Sheffield has been about much more than developing a new client base.

Since starting to explore the local ecosystem, he’s immersed himself in its networks and events, including Geek Brekkie, Sheffield Technology Parks’ Cooper Project and Venture Community.

He’s been struck by the level of activity and, particularly, the willingness of people across different communities to make introductions, share experiences and help one another. As a founder himself, he recognises the value of that support, admitting:

“I’d like to think I’m good at recruitment, but there’s plenty of other things I don’t know how to do, like how to market myself. But when you talk to others, lots of people say the same and are willing to point you in the right direction.”

It’s this collaborative approach that has informed his decision to become an Associate Sponsor of Sheffield Digital.

“I think the first thing for me in exploring this network more is to look at how we can be contributors to it,” he says. For Sam, that means being visible and accessible to businesses, not simply waiting for them to need a paid recruitment service.

He is keen to offer conversations, advice and guidance, helping founders and business leaders think through recruitment challenges before they become formal assignments.

“There’s a lot we can do for free. Of course, if someone comes to us for a search service, that’s where the fee comes in. But anything up to that point, we’ll always have conversations with people. We’ll always help them out and give free advice and guidance.”

His message to founders is straightforward: don’t feel you have to work through recruitment challenges alone. Whether you’re contemplating your first hire, trying to work out what role your business needs next, or struggling to attract the right candidates, Sam is happy to share his expertise and help point you in the right direction.

And that support isn’t limited to start-ups. Anthology North is keen to work with organisations of all sizes, recognising that the principles of good recruitment apply just as much to established teams as they do to early-stage businesses.

As Sam puts it, if there’s one piece of advice he’d give any organisation approaching a recruitment decision, it’s this:

“Ask yourself: What’s the business goal? Everything else you can work backwards from there.”

Find out more about Anthology North: www.anthologynorth.co/.

We’re thrilled to have Sam join us as an Associate Sponsor and look forward to seeing his skills and expertise unfold in the community.

Interested in speaking to Sam? You can connect with him through LinkedIn or get in touch on email to discuss a recruitment challenge. There doesn’t need to be a vacancy on the table to start a conversation.